Custom Cakes

To order custom cakes and special desserts from The Rolling Pin, please allow 48 hours advance notice. For your custom cake, choose your favorite flavors from our wide selection of cakes, frosting and fillings. You may also select to substitute or add a rich mousse, nuts, fresh fruit or liquor to your cake. Our talented bakers will be happy to work with you to realize your special vision.

Cake Ordering Policy

Due to the high volume of orders our shop receives, we ask for a minimum of 48 Hours notice for a cake order. We recommend at least 5 Days to ensure we have adequate time to complete your request.
For special cake designs, we ask for at least 2 Weeks notice. This refers to cake that have fondant details and intricate or large amounts of piping.
Though we work hard to satisfy all our customers needs, please note we cannot replicate exact/identical cake designs as we are likely not the original artists.

Cake Varieties

Vanilla
Chocolate
Almond
Lemon Poppy Seed
Marble
Red Velvet
White
Lavender
Orange (Seasonal)
Pink Lemonade (Seasonal)
Champagne
Confetti (vanilla or white cake with sprinkles)

Frostings

Vanilla
Chocolate
Cream Cheese
Whipped Cream
Any flavor of Mousse or buttercream

Fillings

Vanilla
Chocolate
Cream Cheese
Whipped Cream
Fruit fillings (cherry, raspberry, strawberry)
Lemon Curd
Any flavor of mousse or buttercream

Flavors of buttercream or mousse: strawberry, raspberry, lemon, mint, oreo, almond, champagne, mocha, peanut butter
If you are looking for specific flavors not mentioned, please ask, and we will do our best to accommodate your request.

Sizes

Round 3-Layer Cakes

6" Cake Serves 6-8
8" Cake Serves 12-15
10" Cake Serves 20-25

Double Layer Sheet Cakes

1/4 Sheet Serves 20-24
1/2 Sheet Serves 30-48
Full Sheet Serves 80-96

View Custom Cakes Gallery