2935 S. Fish Hatchery Rd.
Fitchburg, WI 53711
(608) 270-9611
Hours of Operation
Monday-Friday : 7:00 am - 6:00 pm
Saturday : 7:30 am - 4:00 pm
Sunday : Closed
Home | History | Directions | Contact
Photo Gallery

Ordering Information

Specialty Cakes
We have hand-crafted and hand picked the following selection of specialty cakes for your enjoyment. Please allow for a minimum of 24 hours notice. Additional sizes are available. Please inquire for pricing. Decorating fees may apply.

Spotted Cow
Moist chocolate and vanilla cake with chocolate fudge buttercream and chocolate ganache decorated with cow spots.

Brown Spotted Cow
Moist vanilla and chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream and fudge buttercream topped with chocolate ganache and decorated with cow spots.

Strawberry Shortcake
Vanilla cake filled with homemade strawberry filling, fresh strawberries and whipped cream.

Vanilla layers soaked with espresso and liquor filled with Mascarpone filling and whipped.

Hazelnut Mousse
Chocolate cake with hazelnut mousse garnished with nuts and chocolate shavings

Lemon Sunshine
Delicious yellow cake filled with lemon curd and smooth buttercream. Add strawberries to make a Lemon Starburst.

Gourmet Carrot Cake
Moist carrot cake with raisins, pecans and cream cheese frosting.

Sacher Tort
Very rich chocolate almond cake filled with apricot or raspberry puree covered with dark chocolate ganache and garnished with toasted almonds.
6": $25 / 8": $35

Vanilla layers filled with fresh rapsberries and buttercream, covered with marzipan.

Italian Rum Cake
Rum soaked yellow cake layered with rum pastry cream, frosted with cream cheese frosting and garnished with oasted almonds.

Brownie Explosion
Moist chocolate cake filled with rich chocolate mousse and brownie bites.

Mint Chocolate Chip Cake
Moist chocolate cake filled with chocolate mousse and frosted with mint buttercream and decorated with chocolate ganache.

Banana Chocolate Chip Cake
Moist banana chocolate chip cake filled and frosted with cream cheese frosting.

Boston Cream Cake
Yellow cake filled with our homemade custard, topped with chocolate ganache and decorated with cherries.

Black Forest
Chocolate cake filled with real whipped cream and sour cherries with kirsch, garnished with chocolate shavings.

Cappuccino Mousse
Chocolate cake with espresso flavored mousse and chocolate shavings.

Death by Chocolate
Rich chocolate cake filled with French chocolate cream, covered with chocolate fudge and chocolate ganache.

Lemon Poppy Seed Raspberry
Moist cake with raspberry puree and smooth cream cheese frosting.

Raspberry Fudge
Dark moist chocolate cake with raspberries and chocolate buttercream garnished with fresh raspberries and chocolate shavings.

White Chocolate Raspberry Mousse
Vanilla cake with raspberry mousse and raspberry puree covered with white chocolate mousse and white chocolate shavings.

German Chocolate
Buttery coconut pecan filling tops and fills this chocolate classic frosted with dark chocolate fudge.

Chocolate Cherry
Chocolate cake layered with sour cherry and chocolate cream cheese frosting, decorated with dark chocolate shavings.

Orange Chocolate Creamsicle
Light refreshing orange cake filled with our in-house custard and chocolate mousse.

Red Velvet
Dark red velveted chocolate cake filled with silky cream cheese frosting.

Peanut Butter Fudge
Moist chocolate cake filled with a rich peanut butter custard and crunchy peanuts covered in chocolate buttercream and decorated in decadent chocolate ganache.

Cookies and Cream
Moist chocolate cake filled and frosted with crushed Oreos folded into whipped cream.

Custom Cakes
To order custom cakes and special desserts from Rolling Pin, please allow 24-48 hours advance notice.

We also create custom wedding cakes. Please consult our wedding consultant for available styles, prices and delivery options. Visit our Wedding Cake page for more information.

For your custom cake, choose your favorite flavors from our wide selection of cakes, frosting and fillings. A wide range of more elaborate decorations are also available and our bakers will be happy to work with you to realize your special vision. You may also select to substitute or add a rich mousse, nuts, fresh fruit or liquor to your cake.
Cake Varieties
Lemon Poppy Seed
Cream Cheese
Raspberry Buttercream
Whipped Cream
Any flavor of Mousse
Round 3-Layer Cakes Sheet Cakes
6" Cake
8" Cake
10" Cake
Serves 6-8
Serves 12-15
Serves 20-24
1/4 Sheet
1/2 Sheet
Full Sheet
Serves 20-24
Serves 30-48
Serves 80-96